

Pistachio mania: real demand or a rush to imitate?
Article by: Daniele Tirelli, graduate in Physics and Political Science and PhD in Economics. He carried out research at the London School of Economics and KU Leuven. Former Senior Economist at Prometeia and executive at ACNielsen and IRI Infoscan, he has extensive experience in consumer-goods research. He teaches International Economics at the Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia and served as President of the Retail Institute of Italy from 2003 to 2020.
Consumers, industry and retail have imitated one another. As a result, demand for pistachio has ceased to be something to estimate and has largely become a consequence of supply.
A small gallery of “oddities”
In July 2026, 7-Eleven stores in Singapore began selling Pepsi Dubai Chocolate for two Singapore dollars: a sugar-free cola flavoured with chocolate and pistachio that had arrived a few weeks earlier in Thai 7-Eleven stores as well. Testers from the food website Eatbook found only a barely perceptible Dubai flavour, with “a slight chocolate finish, almost nutty”.
It was not the first signal. In 2024, Australian brand Hismile had launched a limited-edition pistachio-flavoured toothpaste inspired by a spread. In Germany, the 60 Seconds to Napoli chain had offered for a few months a pizza with pistachio cream, kadayif and chocolate sauce for €16; in Hamburg, Ottensener Foodkitchen had put on the menu a 150-gram beef burger with guacamole, pistachios, kadayif and, once again, chocolate sauce. In Egypt, during Ramadan 2025, the food press reported Dubai chocolate fries and even ful, the traditional breakfast fava-bean stew, in a green pistachio version. Italy contributed with a sweet pistachio cream with black truffle, produced by Campo d’Oro and nominated in 2025 for Gdoweek’s Better Future Award in the product-innovation category.
The most refined piece in the collection arrived from California at the end of September 2026, when Wonderful Pistachios, a brand dedicated to pistachios, brought Wonderful Pistachios Dubai Chocolate to US supermarkets: pistachios coated in dark chocolate, white chocolate and crunchy kataifi, sold in 4- and 14-ounce bags. Dubai chocolate had started as a chocolate bar filled with pistachio cream; now the pistachio itself was imitating the original bar. Diana Salsa, the company’s Vice President of Marketing, introduced the product by noting that Dubai chocolate had become “a global sensation”, with pistachios “at the centre of the trend”.
Some questions arise. Faced with this collection, one naturally wonders: how does someone come up with a Dubai chocolate cola? It is difficult to imagine the meeting in which a product manager demonstrated, data in hand, that cola drinkers were asking for kataifi. The textbook would say that a new product starts from an identified need, research and testing. Here, the sequence appears different: the product is created because the flavour is already everywhere, and the fact that it is everywhere is taken as proof that the need exists.
The thesis of this article is that, strictly speaking, no one actually thought up these products. A circuit did: consumers, manufacturers, retailers and suppliers watching one another, each using the behaviour of the others as information. A vortex, in other words — and a mimetic one.
The trigger: a chocolate bar and a video
The story is well known, but it is worth summarising. In 2021, Sarah Hamouda, a British-Egyptian entrepreneur based in Dubai, created for her Fix Dessert Chocolatier a chocolate bar filled with pistachio cream and kataifi, the shredded pastry of Middle Eastern tradition, with the playful name “Can’t Get Knafeh of It”. For two years, it remained a local dessert. In December 2023, Ukrainian influencer Maria Vehera unwrapped it in her car in front of a camera on TikTok; the video surpassed one hundred million views.
What followed was a sequence of accelerated diffusion. In November 2024, Lindt launched its own Limited Edition in Germany: one thousand numbered bars in ten stores, priced at up to €20 each. In Stuttgart, a student said he had queued for ten hours; online, the bars were reselling for more than €100, while German customs stopped a man carrying 45 kilos of them from Switzerland. Then came Lidl, Hotel Chocolat, neighbourhood pastry shops and discount retailers.
This first phase was genuinely memetic, in the sense Richard Dawkins gave the word, but the trigger alone does not explain the vortex. Many desserts have gone viral; almost none, so far, have ended up flavouring a cola, a toothpaste and a hamburger.
One herd watching another herd
That consumers imitate one another is nothing new. Harvey Leibenstein described the bandwagon effect in 1950. In 1992, economic theory gave the phenomenon two names in two papers published only months apart. Abhijit Banerjee, winner of the 2019 Nobel Prize, called it herd behavior: when people have to choose, they observe the choices made by those before them and follow them, even against what their own information would suggest. Sushil Bikhchandani, David Hirshleifer and Ivo Welch described the mechanism from another angle: the informational cascade. In short, after a certain number of similar choices, it becomes rational for each person to ignore what they know and follow what they perceive others are doing, and from that point onward the subsequent choices no longer add information.
What is new in the pistachio case lies on the other side of the shelf. Herd behaviour has also spread to companies, for equally rational reasons. As early as 1950, Armen Alchian pointed out that, under uncertainty, imitating those who succeed is a reasonable adaptive rule. Paul DiMaggio and Walter Powell developed this idea further with mimetic isomorphism in 1983, identifying organisations’ tendency to model themselves on competitors when the environment is uncertain. David Scharfstein and Jeremy Stein, in Herd Behavior and Investment in 1990, observed that managers imitate other managers partly to protect their reputations: if an investment fails, it is better if it fails alongside everyone else’s. For a brand manager, then, launching a pistachio SKU becomes a choice that is defensible to their director before it even has to be defended to the consumer.
In Italy, the story had started earlier, and through a side entrance. For decades, to many Italians pistachio was little more than the small green speck inside a slice of Mortadella Bologna IGP. Then Sicilian pastry-making brought it to the forefront and, by 2023, GS1 Italy’s Osservatorio Immagino was already counting 512 products carrying pistachio on the label, up 27% in a single year.
The crucial point, however, is not that the two herds exist. It is that they watch one another. Consumers interpret the presence of pistachio in every aisle as evidence that the flavour is wanted. Producers read competitors’ launches, and the sell-out those launches generate, as proof that demand exists. Each treats as a signal a behaviour that the other produced, at least in part, through imitation.
The multiple vortex
Other herds have joined the first two. Retail buyers ask for a pistachio SKU because the competing banner carries one, and the assortment becomes a coordination device: the presence of the flavour across every retailer becomes social proof for both producers and consumers. Ingredient suppliers offer ready-to-use creams, pastes and chopped nuts, reducing the cost of hybridisation almost to zero. Private labels copy within a few months.
Meteorologists know a phenomenon that closely resembles this: the multiple-vortex tornado, a tornado in which several secondary vortices rotate around a common centre and feed one another. It is the right image for pistachio mania. Not four parallel trends, but one single system in which each actor accelerates the others. In the past, a trend was ridden by a handful of brands, with imitation times measured in seasons. Today the circuit is stronger and faster because everyone contributes to it at the same time.
When demand stops being a data point
This vortex has challenged the traditional way of calculating demand. Classical demand planning treats demand as something external to the company, something to estimate: analysts start from historical sales series, study promotional effects, verify with testing and so on. In a mimetic vortex, several of these assumptions break down.
The first is history. A new craze has no historical series. In their absence, the only available data are competitors’ launches, which measure supply, not demand. Forecasting ends up extrapolating the behaviour of other companies and calling it “the market”.
The second is exogeneity. Observed demand is partly produced by supply itself: by visibility, by presence on every shelf, by repetition.
The third assumption is that the supply chain transmits demand without distorting it: if consumers buy 10% more, orders placed with wholesalers, manufacturers and suppliers should also grow by roughly 10%. In practice, this almost never happens. In 1961, Jay Forrester described the bullwhip effect through his industrial-dynamics models: fluctuations in demand become amplified as they travel upstream from the store towards raw materials.
In 1997, Hau Lee and two colleagues explained its causes. Each operator places orders by looking at the orders received from its direct customer rather than at final consumption, and then adds safety stock. And when a shortage is feared, everyone orders more than necessary to secure their share, causing the shortage to feed itself. This is what happened with pistachio in spring 2025. In the mimetic vortex, there is an extra factor: every operator is also watching competitors.
At the end of the whip, there is a tree
At the far end of the whip, however, there is not a factory that can simply add another shift, but a tree. Which tree, moreover, few people would be able to say: among the many people consuming pistachio in every possible form, almost no one knows whether it grows on a tree, a shrub or a vine. It is a tree: Pistacia vera L., a deciduous species growing up to around ten metres tall, native to Iran and Central Asia and capable of living for as long as three centuries. It belongs to the Anacardiaceae family, which also includes cashew, mango, sumac and, for those who enjoy awkward family relations, poison ivy. It is dioecious: male and female plants are separate, pollen travels on the wind, and only female plants bear fruit. The genus Pistacia contains at least eleven species, including mastic and terebinth, common in the Mediterranean scrub, but only one produces the pistachio we eat.
There are numerous cultivated varieties, but no one has ever definitively counted them. In Iran, the species’ centre of origin, researchers have collected more than three hundred genotypes; the best-known Iranian commercial cultivars are Ohadi, Kalleh Ghouchi, Akbari and Ahmad Aghaei. Turkey mainly grows Uzun and Kırmızı, Greece the Aegina variety, Sicily the Napoletana, also known as Bianca or Nostrale, which in Bronte is grafted onto terebinth and grows on volcanic soils between 400 and 900 metres above sea level. California, meanwhile, built the world’s leading industry largely around a single pair: the female Kerman, selected from a batch of seeds collected in Iran in 1929 by botanical explorer William Whitehouse and released by the Department of Agriculture in 1957, and the male Peters. The cultivar takes its name from the Iranian province from which it originated.
Most importantly, it is a slow tree. According to California’s Administrative Committee for Pistachios, a tree takes around six years from planting to its first harvest and more than ten years to reach full production; in addition, it alternates between heavy-crop and light-crop years. It is probably the least suitable raw material for chasing TikTok.
The consequences became visible quickly. In spring 2025, according to data reported by the Financial Times, the price of kernels had risen in one year from $7.65 to $10.30 per pound; Iranian exports to the United Arab Emirates were up 40%, while US availability had fallen by 20%. In the 2025/26 season, the United States’ record harvest — 713,000 tonnes according to the Department of Agriculture — partly offset Turkey’s collapse of almost 70%. For the 2026/27 season, however, some industry forecasts were already pointing to a US crop almost halved because of alternate bearing.
Italy, meanwhile, was experiencing the paradox of imported enthusiasm. In 2024, the country produced around 4,000 tonnes of pistachios and imported around 32,000 tonnes, more than half from the United States: 88% of demand was met from abroad. Pistacchio Verde di Bronte DOP, the national symbol of the flavour, accounted for 341 tonnes. Italian pistachio mania was, to a large extent, a Californian mania; and, one step further back in the genealogy, an Iranian one.
When the herd converges on a rigid raw material, costs rise, margins shrink and companies begin looking for formulations with less pistachio or smaller packs. This is the vortex’s natural brake and, at the same time, its risk: the ingredient that had made the product desirable becomes the variable to compress.
The circle closes
This is where the Wonderful Pistachios product stops being a curiosity and becomes a symptom. A company that sells pistachios chased a trend born from a pistachio dessert. The raw material imitated the product that was imitating it, and the vortex began turning back on itself.
Two consequences deserve attention. The first concerns competitive advantage. Wroe Alderson described competition as a continuous search for differential advantage. When everyone has pistachio, pistachio stops differentiating: it moves from distinctive attribute to category requirement. Those who arrived first enjoyed a few months of distinction; those who arrive last pay the cost of presence without gaining visibility.
The second concerns duration. The same Harvey Leibenstein who described the bandwagon effect also described, in the same paper, the snob effect: abandoning a form of consumption once everyone adopts it. A circuit that accelerates on the way up also accelerates on the way down, and the more compressed the cycle, the sooner fatigue arrives. It is the same warning offered by informational cascades: when they are built on little information, very little is needed to stop them.
Fad or trend: how to tell
There is a way to understand which way the vortex is turning, and it involves comparing two series that are usually examined separately. The first measures supply: how many pistachio SKUs exist in each category and how much time passes between one launch and its imitation. The second measures demand in the strict sense: household penetration and, above all, the repurchase rate, which separates those who tried from those who adopted. If SKUs grow faster than repurchase, the producers’ herd is running ahead of the consumers’ herd, and what appears to be a trend is actually a supply-driven fad.
For those deciding on the next launch, the practical recommendation is easy to state and difficult to follow: look at repurchase data before looking at the competitor’s shelf. The competitor, in all likelihood, was looking at ours.
Sources (notes for the author)
Eatbook (8 July 2026), Pepsi Has New Dubai Chocolate Flavour At 7-Eleven; Trend Hunter (9 June 2026), Chocolate-Pistachio Sodas (Thailand).
Trend Hunter (29 February 2024), Pistachio-Flavored Toothpastes (Hismile Pistachio Papi).
Bluewin, Dubai chocolate is now also available as a pizza or burger (60 Seconds to Napoli; Ottensener Foodkitchen).
CairoScene (24 March 2025), Dubai Chocolate Fries and Pistachio Foul Are Just the Start.
Gdoweek (19 March 2025), Crema dolce di pistacchio con tartufo nero, Better Future Award 2025.
The Shelby Report (29 September 2026), Wonderful Pistachios Joins Dubai Chocolate Trend With New Flavor.
Smithsonian Magazine (4 April 2025), The TikTok-Famous Dubai Chocolate Traces Its Origins to the 13th-Century Middle East; Fortune/AFP (25 November 2024), Europe goes nuts for viral Dubai chocolate.
FoodIngredientsFirst, Pistachio evolves from flavor trend into cross-category growth opportunity (Innova Market Insights data).
Il Sole 24 Ore (23 January 2023), Vola la domanda di pistacchio, la Spagna ne approfitta, l’Italia no (GS1 Italy, Osservatorio Immagino data; statement by Marco Cuppini).
FoodNavigator (22 April 2025), Dubai chocolate craze causes global pistachio shortage (Financial Times data, UAE customs, Administrative Committee for Pistachios).
FreshPlaza (20 February 2026), Global pistachio production forecast down 8% in 2025/26 (USDA FAS); CMB News (5 June 2026), 2026/27 forecasts.
Qualivita / Il Sole 24 Ore (26 February 2026), Pistacchio, corrono i consumi in Italia ma l’88% proviene dall’estero(Ismea and Istat data).
California Foundation for Agriculture in the Classroom, Pistachios fact sheet (Administrative Committee for Pistachios data).
Consorzio Mortadella Bologna, Disciplinare di produzione della Mortadella Bologna IGP (2021), art. 3.
Wikipedia, Pistachio (classification, habit, longevity, family); EUFORGEN, Pistacia vera (species in the genus according to Karcı et al. 2022, dioecy, wind pollination).
Mahdavi et al. (2021), Genetic diversity and population structure of Iranian pistachio cultivars (more than 300 genotypes collected in Iran).
Dan Parfitt, Craig Kallsen, Joseph Maranto, Pistachio Cultivars, The Orchard, University of California ANR (Kerman, Peters, cultivars by country); Atlas Obscura (11 February 2019), Where Are Pistachios From.
Disciplinare del Pistacchio Verde di Bronte DOP, arts. 2-5 (Napoletana cultivar, grafting on Pistacia terebinthus, volcanic soils, altitude 400-900 m).
Harvey Leibenstein (1950), Bandwagon, Snob, and Veblen Effects in the Theory of Consumers’ Demand, Quarterly Journal of Economics; Abhijit Banerjee (1992), A Simple Model of Herd Behavior, Quarterly Journal of Economics; Sushil Bikhchandani, David Hirshleifer, Ivo Welch (1992), A Theory of Fads, Fashion, Custom, and Cultural Change as Informational Cascades, Journal of Political Economy; Armen Alchian (1950), Journal of Political Economy; Paul DiMaggio, Walter Powell (1983), American Sociological Review; David Scharfstein, Jeremy Stein (1990), Herd Behavior and Investment, American Economic Review; Jay Forrester (1961), Industrial Dynamics; Hau Lee et al. (1997), Sloan Management Review.

We increase your company's long-term value
Discover our consulting services